Skip to content

[codex] Add auto-heal bot smoke PR#3

Draft
BLamy wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
codex/autoheal-bot-smoke
Draft

[codex] Add auto-heal bot smoke PR#3
BLamy wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
codex/autoheal-bot-smoke

Conversation

@BLamy
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@BLamy BLamy commented May 18, 2026

Summary

Adds a harmless marker file so we can exercise the Replay auto-heal bot flow against a fresh PR created from main.

Validation

  • Not run; documentation-only smoke marker.

@replay-io
Copy link
Copy Markdown

replay-io Bot commented May 18, 2026

replay-mcp-lab-next#‍8.1

Status Complete ↗︎
Commit 02321d4
Results
1 Failed
  • intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail (Replay 1, Replay 2)
  • 7 Passed
  • DOM layout exposes inspectable ancestry and overlap target
  • happy path captures console, storage, network, screenshots, and clicks
  • profiling creates bounded CPU and dependency graph activity
  • React exception records boundary context and component stack
  • runtime exception records an uncaught browser error
  • source and logpoint exposes stable functions and console values
  • state and React captures Redux, Zustand, TanStack Query, and render activity
  • replay-mcp-lab-tanstack-start#‍8.1

    Status Complete ↗︎
    Commit 02321d4
    Results
    1 Failed
  • intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail (Replay 1, Replay 2)
  • 7 Passed
  • DOM layout exposes inspectable ancestry and overlap target
  • happy path captures console, storage, network, screenshots, and clicks
  • profiling creates bounded CPU and dependency graph activity
  • React exception records boundary context and component stack
  • runtime exception records an uncaught browser error
  • source and logpoint exposes stable functions and console values
  • state and React captures Redux, Zustand, TanStack Query, and render activity
  • replay-mcp-lab-vite#‍8.1

    Status Complete ↗︎
    Commit 02321d4
    Results
    1 Failed
  • intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail (Replay 1, Replay 2)
  • 7 Passed
  • DOM layout exposes inspectable ancestry and overlap target
  • happy path captures console, storage, network, screenshots, and clicks
  • profiling creates bounded CPU and dependency graph activity
  • React exception records boundary context and component stack
  • runtime exception records an uncaught browser error
  • source and logpoint exposes stable functions and console values
  • state and React captures Redux, Zustand, TanStack Query, and render activity
  • @replay-test
    Copy link
    Copy Markdown

    replay-test Bot commented May 18, 2026

    replay-mcp-lab-next#‍8.1

    Status Complete ↗︎
    Commit 02321d4
    Results
    1 Failed

    Auto-heal queue: check tests below, then Analyze checked or Fix checked. Links open a confirmation page; checked boxes are read from this comment only after you submit.

    Error: expect(locator).toHaveText(expected) failed
    Locator: getByTestId('checkout-total')
    Expected: "$999.00"
    Received: "$128.40"
    Timeout: 500ms
    ```

    7 Passed
  • DOM layout exposes inspectable ancestry and overlap target
  • happy path captures console, storage, network, screenshots, and clicks
  • profiling creates bounded CPU and dependency graph activity
  • React exception records boundary context and component stack
  • runtime exception records an uncaught browser error
  • source and logpoint exposes stable functions and console values
  • state and React captures Redux, Zustand, TanStack Query, and render activity
  • replay-mcp-lab-tanstack-start#‍8.1

    Status Complete ↗︎
    Commit 02321d4
    Results
    1 Failed

    Auto-heal queue: check tests below, then Analyze checked or Fix checked. Links open a confirmation page; checked boxes are read from this comment only after you submit.

    Error: expect(locator).toHaveText(expected) failed
    Locator: getByTestId('checkout-total')
    Expected: "$999.00"
    Received: "$128.40"
    Timeout: 500ms
    ```

    7 Passed
  • DOM layout exposes inspectable ancestry and overlap target
  • happy path captures console, storage, network, screenshots, and clicks
  • profiling creates bounded CPU and dependency graph activity
  • React exception records boundary context and component stack
  • runtime exception records an uncaught browser error
  • source and logpoint exposes stable functions and console values
  • state and React captures Redux, Zustand, TanStack Query, and render activity
  • replay-mcp-lab-vite#‍8.1

    Status Complete ↗︎
    Commit 02321d4
    Results
    1 Failed

    Auto-heal queue: check tests below, then Analyze checked or Fix checked. Links open a confirmation page; checked boxes are read from this comment only after you submit.

    Error: expect(locator).toHaveText(expected) failed
    Locator: getByTestId('checkout-total')
    Expected: "$999.00"
    Received: "$128.40"
    Timeout: 500ms
    ```

    7 Passed
  • DOM layout exposes inspectable ancestry and overlap target
  • happy path captures console, storage, network, screenshots, and clicks
  • profiling creates bounded CPU and dependency graph activity
  • React exception records boundary context and component stack
  • runtime exception records an uncaught browser error
  • source and logpoint exposes stable functions and console values
  • state and React captures Redux, Zustand, TanStack Query, and render activity
  • @replay-io
    Copy link
    Copy Markdown

    replay-io Bot commented May 18, 2026

    Replay failure analysis

    Test: intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail
    Recording: Open Replay recording

    Root Cause [high confidence]
    The test assertion in registerPlaywrightFailureSpec() at playwright.ts:105 expects "$999.00" but the PlaywrightFailureScenario component (App.tsx:647) hardcodes the checkout total as "$128.40". This is an intentional mismatch — the scenario is classified as kind: "diagnostic-failure" in metadata.ts and exists to exercise Replay's ability to capture and expose failing Playwright step details. There is no application bug; the test is designed to fail.

    Failure Sequence
    The test navigates to /playwright-failure, waits for hydration, clicks "Confirm Checkout" (which only logs to console), then asserts that the element with data-testid="checkout-total" has text "$999.00". The PlaywrightFailureScenario component renders a hardcoded "$128.40" in that element. The assertion fails immediately because "$128.40" !== "$999.00", and times out after 500ms of retries.

    Suggested Fix
    No fix is needed for the application code. The test is intentionally designed to fail as a diagnostic scenario to verify Replay can capture failing Playwright step details. If the intent is to make this test pass, change the expected value on line 105 of playwright.ts from "$999.00" to "$128.40".

    Affected Files

    • replay-mcp-lab-core/src/playwright.ts

    Category: test_issue
    Confidence: high — Test name, step name, and scenario metadata (kind: "diagnostic-failure") all explicitly declare this is deliberately failing. The hardcoded UI value ($128.40) is consistent across App.tsx, state.ts, and api.ts — no application bug exists.

    Suggested Follow-Up
    Verify that the CI pipeline properly handles diagnostic-failure scenarios — these intentionally-failing tests should be excluded from the pass/fail gate or annotated with an expected-failure marker so they don't block builds.

    Fix Prompt (for coding agent)

    If you want this test to pass, edit replay-mcp-lab-core/src/playwright.ts line 105: change the expected text from "$999.00" to "$128.40". However, this test is intentionally failing — its purpose (per metadata.ts kind: "diagnostic-failure") is to exercise Replay's failing-step capture. Making it pass would defeat its purpose. The correct action is to mark this test as expected-to-fail or exclude it from CI pass/fail gating.

    Evidence Trail
    • Read test source (Read replay-mcp-lab-core/src/playwright.ts): The test step at line 104 is explicitly named 'intentional wrong total assertion' and expects '$999.00' with a 500ms timeout. The test function is named 'intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail'.
    • Examine component source (Read replay-mcp-lab-core/src/App.tsx): PlaywrightFailureScenario (line 640-656) renders a hardcoded checkout total: $128.40. No dynamic calculation or data fetching involved.
    • Check scenario metadata (Read replay-mcp-lab-core/src/metadata.ts): The playwright-failure scenario has kind: 'diagnostic-failure' (line 117), confirming it is intentionally designed to fail for Replay tooling coverage of PlaywrightSteps, Screenshot, and ConsoleMessages.
    • Verify data consistency (Read replay-mcp-lab-core/src/state.ts and api.ts): Both Redux initial state (state.ts:20, amount: 128.4) and API items (api.ts:20, value: 128.4) use 128.4 as the order amount. $999.00 has no source anywhere in the codebase.
    • Check Playwright steps (Replay PlaywrightSteps): Step 4 at 591ms shows the toHaveText assertion on getByTestId('checkout-total') expecting '$999.00'. The assertion fails because actual text is '$128.40'. No prior steps modify the checkout total.
    • Recording overview (Replay RecordingOverview): No console errors or warnings. All 33 network requests succeeded. The app is healthy — the only failure is the intentional test assertion mismatch.

    @replay-test
    Copy link
    Copy Markdown

    replay-test Bot commented May 18, 2026

    🔴 Replay failure analysis

    Test: intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail
    Recording: Open in Replay →


    Root cause   confidence

    The test assertion expects "$999.00" but the PlaywrightFailureScenario component hardcodes the checkout total as "$128.40" in a static <strong> element (App.tsx line 647). There is no dynamic pricing logic, no state management, and no API call — the value is a literal string in the JSX. This is a deliberate mismatch: the test is intentionally designed to fail in order to exercise Playwright step-failure reporting in the Replay MCP lab test suite.

    Failure sequence

    Step What happened
    1 Playwright navigates to /playwright-failure and waits for hydration.
    2 PlaywrightFailureScenario renders with a hardcoded checkout total of "$128.40" (App.tsx:647).
    3 Test clicks "Confirm Checkout" button (which only logs to console, does not change any state).
    4 Test asserts getByTestId('checkout-total') has text "$999.00", but the element contains "$128.40".
    5 Assertion fails after 500ms timeout — the value never changes because it is static.

    Suggested fix

    # Fix Detail
    1 Align the hardcoded value Change the hardcoded total in PlaywrightFailureScenario from "$128.40" to "$999.00" in replay-mcp-lab-core/src/App.tsx line 647.
    2 OR align the test assertion Change the expected value in replay-mcp-lab-core/src/playwright.ts line 105 from "$999.00" to "$128.40". Note: Since this is an intentional failure for testing Replay's failure-analysis tooling, the "fix" depends on whether the team wants this test to pass or remain as a deliberate failure fixture.

    Affected files: replay-mcp-lab-core/src/App.tsx, replay-mcp-lab-core/src/playwright.ts

    Category: test_issue  ·  Confidence: high — Unambiguous: component hardcodes "$128.40" (confirmed in source and recording), test asserts "$999.00". The step is named "intentional wrong total assertion". No dynamic logic exists.

    Suggested follow-up:
    Confirm with the team whether this test is meant to remain as a permanent failure fixture for testing Replay's failure-analysis tooling, or if it should be updated to pass. If permanent, consider a skip annotation or dedicated "expected failures" suite to avoid polluting CI.

    Fix prompt (for coding agent)

    This is an intentional test failure used as a fixture for testing Replay's MCP failure-analysis tools. If the goal is to make the test pass, apply ONE of these changes:

    Option A — Fix the component value (if $999.00 is the "correct" price):

    In replay-mcp-lab-core/src/App.tsx line 647, change:

    <strong data-testid="checkout-total">$128.40</strong>

    to:

    <strong data-testid="checkout-total">$999.00</strong>

    Option B — Fix the test assertion (if $128.40 is the "correct" price):

    In replay-mcp-lab-core/src/playwright.ts line 105, change:

    await expect(page.getByTestId("checkout-total")).toHaveText("$999.00", { timeout: 500 });

    to:

    await expect(page.getByTestId("checkout-total")).toHaveText("$128.40", { timeout: 500 });

    Do NOT change both files — pick one source of truth. Do not add dynamic pricing logic; the component is intentionally simple.

    Evidence trail
    Tool Finding
    PlaywrightSteps (test-source) Read test source and failure output The test at playwright.ts:105 asserts checkout-total has text "$999.00" with a 500ms timeout. The step is explicitly named "intentional wrong total assertion", confirming this is a deliberate failure.
    SearchSources + ReadSource Locate component rendering checkout-total In App.tsx line 647, PlaywrightFailureScenario renders $128.40 — a hardcoded static string with no state, props, or API dependency.
    Read replay-mcp-lab-core/src/App.tsx Verify no dynamic pricing logic exists The PlaywrightFailureScenario function (lines 640-656) contains no React state, no useEffect, no API calls, and no props. The $128.40 value is a JSX string literal that can never change at runtime.
    ReadSource (runtime hits) Confirm button click has no side effects on total The Confirm Checkout button's onClick handler (line 649) only calls console.info("Checkout confirmed") — hit count 1 confirms it fired once. No state update occurs, so the total stays $128.40.
    PlaywrightSteps (steps) Verify via Playwright step timeline Step 3 clicks Confirm Checkout at 1549ms, step 4 asserts checkout-total text at 1599ms. The assertion finds "$128.40" which doesn't match "$999.00", and times out after 500ms of retries.
    PlaywrightSteps (summary) Confirm test name indicates intentional design Test title is "intentional Playwright failure exposes failing step detail" — this is a test fixture designed to produce a Playwright failure for Replay's MCP analysis tools, not a real product bug.

    Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

    Labels

    None yet

    Projects

    None yet

    Development

    Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

    1 participant